• 2019 Activity Analysis
  • About the Commonwealth Contest and BERU
  • DX QTHs for would be DXpeditioners…
    • Grenada sites
  • DXpedition reports 1996 to 2014
    • 2011 J68PJ
    • 2011 VO2AC
    • 2012 6Y0A – A Yankee Clipper in Her Majesty’s Commonwealth Contest
    • 2012 9H3C
    • 2012 9H3ET
    • 2012 VP9/G3PJT
    • 2013 9H3ET
    • 2013 9X1NH
    • 2013 C4I Cyprus
    • 2013 J34G Grenada
    • 2013 Bermuda G4CWH/VP9
    • 2014 9H3AL Gozo
    • 2014 9X0NH – JOIN THE COMMONWEALTH CONTEST WEDDING!
    • 2014 C5/M1KTA Dom
    • 2014 J34G
    • 2014 Labrador – VO2AAA
    • 2014 VY2GQ – or G3LET encounters a ‘super-station
  • DXpedition Reports 2015 –
    • 2015 BERU from Kenya – 5Z4LS
    • 2015 J34G Grenada Round 3 Part 1
    • 2015 J34G Grenada Round 3 Part 2
    • 2015 V5/G3TXF
    • 2015 – VP9/G3VYI
    • 2015 – VY2GQ
    • 2016 A25MC
    • 2016 J34G
    • 2016 J79XF
    • 2016 VE2AEJ
    • 2016 VO1LET
    • 2017 3B8/G3TXF
    • 2017 8P9IF (extended and with pictures)
    • 2017 C4I update
    • 2017 E51KTA
    • 2017 E51KTA more pictures
    • 2017 VY2GQ ( extended with pictures)
    • 2017 ZF2CA
    • 2018 – 9H3ET
    • 2018 9H3ET pictures
    • 2018 9M6/G3VYI
    • 2018 V31GX
    • 2018 ZF2CA
    • 2018 ZF2CA travel epilogue
    • 2019 C56DF
    • 2019 Travellers report ZF2CA
    • 2019 Travellers Tales 3B8XF
    • 2019 V31GX
    • 2019 VY2/G3VYI
    • BERU Report from VP9I
    • C6AKT
      • 2019 C6AKT Part 2
  • G3PJT Commonwealth Contest DXpeditions
  • Getting started …
    • Don, G3XTT, Practical Wireless article on BERU propagation
    • Software …
  • Reflections in a Rosebowl
  • Results
    • 2007 result
    • 2008 Result
    • 2009 Results
    • 2010 Results
    • 2011 Results
    • 2012 75th Contest
    • 2013 Results
    • 2014 Results
    • 2015 Results
    • 2016 Results
    • 2017 Results
      • 2017 Activity
      • UK HQ stations Gx80CC
    • 2018 Results
    • 2019 Results
    • 2020 Results
    • 2021 Results
    • 2022 Results
    • 2023 Results
  • RSGB Convention talk
  • Rules 2023
  • Trophies
    • Miniatures for the Open winners …
    • Open Unassisted Section
    • Restricted Section
    • John Dunnington Trophy
    • Lilliput Cup
    • The Rosebery Shield
    • Ross Carey Rose Bowl
    • VP8GQ Trophy
    • Commonwealth Medal
    • QRP Certificate
    • Commonwealth Traveller
    • Certificates

Commonwealth Contest

~ A DX contest and DX means long distance and challenging radio contacts. News and Information. ****87th Contest 9 and 10 March 2024*****

Commonwealth Contest

Monthly Archives: June 2015

RSGB HFCC White paper comments from G3RWF

25 Thursday Jun 2015

Posted by bobg3pjt in Reports

≈ Leave a comment

Comments on the Commonwealth Contest (White paper Paras 2.10 and 6.9)

I am a keen participant in the Commonwealth Contest. Since 2008 I have put on a CC station from Africa 7 times (Uganda 4, Rwanda 2 and Kenya 1). I would be reluctant to see it become “World works the Commonwealth” as that would change the character of this oldest of contests.

The unique characteristic of CC is that stations with low power and simple antennas can work Commonwealth stations across the world. CW speeds are relatively modest and it is suitable for old timers and new comers. It is conducted with some courtesy. Some love it for that – others don’t. I usually enter the restricted class (100w and wire antenna) and have done so quite successfully, even at sunspot minimum . With that power and antenna I am unable to get into other worldwide contests from East Africa in any serious way – and I know because I have tried. For them I need more gain (a beam) and preferably more power. CC has a place as a “simpler” contest.

I suspect the main pressure for change to CC comes from those who want to amass many more contacts than are currently possible in CC. The CC is not for them – there are plenty of other contests where the main theme is run like a maniac and “pile ‘em high”. “Commonwealth works the world” would undoubtedly bring out the contest “big guns” who swamp the bands on a regular basis in the larger contests.

When I first entered CC (in 1969 from Kenya) there were many expatriate and local “overseas” stations to liven up the contest. Now it is very dependent on travellers to provide variety. For the present that is probably (just) sustainable.

The CC is a quite disciplined contest. It lasts only 24 hours and contestants stick quite closely to a section of the CW allocation – not all over the bands. I recommend little change – although the scoring to advantage relatively rare calls might be increased (I made a separate suggestion for that after the 2015 contest). I support the proposal that CQs should be “CQ CC” – “CQ BERU” is impossible to explain.

Outside CC there are two areas where the RSGB could consider change. The 21/28 Contest has, in my view, run its course in its present form. As sunspots diminish it will be increasingly difficult to get much out of it. That contest slot could be ideal base for an RSGB international contest – if that is the wish. Also I would draw attention to the All Africa contest which was organised last year by SARL. It clashed with CC and was advertised far too late to be successful. However the concept has merit and RSGB might consider working with SARL to develop it.
Nick Henwood G3RWF

(Also 5X1NH, 9X0NH and 5Z4LS in CC)

RSGB Rule Change Proposal White Paper 2015 G3PJT comments

24 Wednesday Jun 2015

Posted by bobg3pjt in Reports

≈ Leave a comment

G3PJT Comments in red – non Commonwealth comments removed. .

1. Overall general proposals

1.1. Establish a facility to publish HF and VHF logs to permit propagation analysis I support these ideas

1.2. Investigate the potential for verified QSOs in adjudicated contest logs to automatically become valid for the RSGB VHF/UHF Award programmes.I support this idea

1.4. Reduce the entry period for all contests (except IOTA) to 7 days except by prior arrangement with the contest adjudicator. The entry period for IOTA will remain at 21 days.

I agree with this for predominantly national contests but for international ones like IOTA and Commonwealth it should be one month as taking account that although internet is becoming global there are often occasions when reliance on postal mail is the only route to submit. In addition in Commonwealth we often have to chase up entries from active DX stations so we need a month to give us time to do this.

2.10. Commonwealth Contest – Change the format so that the World can work the Commonwealth

As a long term non-UK entrant to the Commonwealth Contest I do NOT support this proposal. Basically I believe it is misconceived. As you know the number of entrants has been steadily growing over the last 10-15 years with a bit of a plateau recently ( https://berucontest.wordpress.com/results/ ). Our approach to achieve this increasing participation has been by better marketing, communication and periodic special prizes.

This proposed change crops up from time to time. We have to work out the benefits to current and potential participants and whether this proposal is going to be a change for the better measured by more activity/entrants/fun , so

– will this lead to greater participation of UK,?

– will this lead to more VK/ZL/ VE?

– will more Commonwealth stations become more active?

– will we all go travelling to interesting Commonwealth countries?

My view is that we might be reaching a real plateau in participation in VK and ZL but will opening this up to ROW bring a new set of VKs or ZLs out of the outback? I don’t think so as I am not sure they even exist. And after all, I guess that the big VK/ZL stns are pretty busy anyway. As far as Rest of the Commonwealth are concerned they have to be encouraged to view this contest as their ‘special one’ by virtue of they being members of the Commonwealth family. As far as the average UK station is concerned then the Commonwealth Contest provides a good opportunity to work some more unusual DX stations and for some, that might only mean VK/ZL/VU. Yes that’s right, not rare in the DXers world, but if you are struggling in a poor radio situation then QSOs to be proud of. But that depends on getting more Commonwealth stations on the air for that weekend, easier said than done.

What we have been trying to create is a true DX contest where you have to turn that big knob on the front and listen a bit. As this is an RSGB sponsored contest it should favour RSGB membership, and that means not opening it up to all and sundry. Some of the new contesters favour having ‘open’ contests but when I asked them, ‘ in that case would you enter if the Commonwealth was open?’ The response was only a qualified maybe, which is hardly enough to warrant a change.

If Contest Com. wanted to try experiments to build activity why not use the 21/28 as a testbed? After all that’s an ‘open’ type of contest and could use some fresh ideas, I understand.

Finally in ‘open’ contests look at the way the big multi-ops act to dominate the bands, even in IOTA. Almost like they are having their own ‘open’ contest working each other and thus the IOTA DXpeds with lowish power can’t get a look in despite the scoring benefits. In BERU, sorry CC, that would happen for sure if it were made open. This proposal therefore should not be adopted..

6.8. BERU – To assist identifying QRP stations, remove the requirement to put QRP in the Cabrillo header and add a requirement to enter the power output used when submitting the log. I support this idea

6.9. BERU – In the rules, change all references to BERU to Commonwealth Contest and suggest entrants call CQ CC not CQ BERU. By all means have consistent labelling in the rules. We have problems with unwanted callers, the merit of using ‘CQ BERU’ is that it has a brand image, saying ‘Commonwealth Stations only please, just for now’. It will take a good few years for ‘CQ BERU’ to be replaced by ‘CQ CC’ – if ever!

BTW – my thanks to the committee for all the hard work you are putting in!
73 Bob G3PJT

Rule Change Proposals RSGB HFCC White Paper 2015

22 Monday Jun 2015

Posted by bobg3pjt in Reports

≈ 2 Comments

Rule Change Proposals RSGB HFCC White Paper 2015
Precis for Commonwealth Contest entrants
This document outlines suggestions and proposals for rule changes for both HF and VHF contests in 2016. Comments on these items are invited. Please send your comments to committee@rsgbcc.org no later than 7th August 2015. All comments will be reviewed by the RSGB Contest Committee (CC) during August and September and revised rules for all RSGB contests will be published as soon as possible after the review. All rule changes will take effect on 1st January 2016.

2.10. Commonwealth Contest – Change the format so that the World can work the Commonwealth.
6.8. BERU – To assist identifying QRP stations, remove the requirement to put QRP in the Cabrillo header and add a requirement to enter the power output used when submitting the log.
6.9. BERU – In the rules, change all references to BERU to Commonwealth Contest and suggest entrants call CQ CC not CQ BERU.

THESE ARE JUST PROPOSALS.

Subscribe

  • Entries (RSS)
  • Comments (RSS)

Archives

  • April 2023
  • March 2023
  • February 2023
  • January 2023
  • November 2022
  • July 2022
  • June 2022
  • May 2022
  • April 2022
  • March 2022
  • February 2022
  • January 2022
  • December 2021
  • November 2021
  • October 2021
  • July 2021
  • April 2021
  • March 2021
  • February 2021
  • January 2021
  • September 2020
  • April 2020
  • March 2020
  • February 2020
  • January 2020
  • December 2019
  • November 2019
  • April 2019
  • March 2019
  • February 2019
  • January 2019
  • December 2018
  • November 2018
  • October 2018
  • September 2018
  • April 2018
  • March 2018
  • February 2018
  • January 2018
  • November 2017
  • September 2017
  • August 2017
  • July 2017
  • May 2017
  • April 2017
  • March 2017
  • February 2017
  • January 2017
  • December 2016
  • November 2016
  • October 2016
  • September 2016
  • August 2016
  • July 2016
  • June 2016
  • May 2016
  • April 2016
  • March 2016
  • February 2016
  • January 2016
  • November 2015
  • September 2015
  • July 2015
  • June 2015
  • March 2015
  • February 2015
  • January 2015
  • December 2014

Categories

  • DXpeditions
  • HQ Stations
  • News
  • Reports
  • Results
  • Teams
  • Uncategorized

Meta

  • Register
  • Log in

Blog at WordPress.com.

  • Follow Following
    • Commonwealth Contest
    • Join 165 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Commonwealth Contest
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar