• 2019 Activity Analysis
  • About the Commonwealth Contest and BERU
  • DX QTHs for would be DXpeditioners…
    • Grenada sites
  • DXpedition reports 1996 to 2014
    • 2011 J68PJ
    • 2011 VO2AC
    • 2012 6Y0A – A Yankee Clipper in Her Majesty’s Commonwealth Contest
    • 2012 9H3C
    • 2012 9H3ET
    • 2012 VP9/G3PJT
    • 2013 9H3ET
    • 2013 9X1NH
    • 2013 C4I Cyprus
    • 2013 J34G Grenada
    • 2013 Bermuda G4CWH/VP9
    • 2014 9H3AL Gozo
    • 2014 9X0NH – JOIN THE COMMONWEALTH CONTEST WEDDING!
    • 2014 C5/M1KTA Dom
    • 2014 J34G
    • 2014 Labrador – VO2AAA
    • 2014 VY2GQ – or G3LET encounters a ‘super-station
  • DXpedition Reports 2015 –
    • 2015 BERU from Kenya – 5Z4LS
    • 2015 J34G Grenada Round 3 Part 1
    • 2015 J34G Grenada Round 3 Part 2
    • 2015 V5/G3TXF
    • 2015 – VP9/G3VYI
    • 2015 – VY2GQ
    • 2016 A25MC
    • 2016 J34G
    • 2016 J79XF
    • 2016 VE2AEJ
    • 2016 VO1LET
    • 2017 3B8/G3TXF
    • 2017 8P9IF (extended and with pictures)
    • 2017 C4I update
    • 2017 E51KTA
    • 2017 E51KTA more pictures
    • 2017 VY2GQ ( extended with pictures)
    • 2017 ZF2CA
    • 2018 – 9H3ET
    • 2018 9H3ET pictures
    • 2018 9M6/G3VYI
    • 2018 V31GX
    • 2018 ZF2CA
    • 2018 ZF2CA travel epilogue
    • 2019 C56DF
    • 2019 Travellers report ZF2CA
    • 2019 Travellers Tales 3B8XF
    • 2019 V31GX
    • 2019 VY2/G3VYI
    • BERU Report from VP9I
    • C6AKT
      • 2019 C6AKT Part 2
  • G3PJT Commonwealth Contest DXpeditions
  • Getting started …
    • Don, G3XTT, Practical Wireless article on BERU propagation
    • Software …
  • Reflections in a Rosebowl
  • Results
    • 2007 result
    • 2008 Result
    • 2009 Results
    • 2010 Results
    • 2011 Results
    • 2012 75th Contest
    • 2013 Results
    • 2014 Results
    • 2015 Results
    • 2016 Results
    • 2017 Results
      • 2017 Activity
      • UK HQ stations Gx80CC
    • 2018 Results
    • 2019 Results
    • 2020 Results
    • 2021 Results
    • 2022 Results
    • 2023 Results
  • RSGB Convention talk
  • Rules 2023
  • Trophies
    • Miniatures for the Open winners …
    • Open Unassisted Section
    • Restricted Section
    • John Dunnington Trophy
    • Lilliput Cup
    • The Rosebery Shield
    • Ross Carey Rose Bowl
    • VP8GQ Trophy
    • Commonwealth Medal
    • QRP Certificate
    • Commonwealth Traveller
    • Certificates

Commonwealth Contest

~ A DX contest and DX means long distance and challenging radio contacts. News and Information. ****87th Contest 9 and 10 March 2024*****

Commonwealth Contest

Monthly Archives: July 2015

Lee Jennings ZL2AL silent key

21 Tuesday Jul 2015

Posted by bobg3pjt in Reports

≈ Leave a comment

Lee ZL2AL was a regular entrant to the Commonwealth Contest for many years and was the founder and leader of the ZM4T (formerly ZM2M) contest team which has entered the contest regularly since 2009.

Comments on White Paper 2015 from Alan VE3HX

10 Friday Jul 2015

Posted by bobg3pjt in Reports

≈ Leave a comment

From: ve3hx [mailto:ve3hx@rogers.com]
Sent: 10 July 2015 04:43
To: John Gould
Subject: Comments on White Paper 2015

Dear Dr. Gould,

Below please find a copy of a letter I am sending to the Contest Committee.

BERU has been my favourite contest for many years and I trust proposed
changes 2.10 and 6.9 won’t be made. They seem to be a sure way to ruin a
well run and adjudicated contest.

Sincerely,

Alan Goodacre VE3HX
1286 Woodside Drive
Ottawa, Ontario
K2C 2G9
Canada
July 9, 2015
RSGB Contest Committee
Radio Society of Great Britain
3 Abbey Court
Priory Business Park
Bedford
MK44 3WH
England, UK

Gentlemen,

In the July issue of RadCom you very thoughtfully ask for comments about
the Contest Committee’s 2015 White Paper so I would like to offer the
following comments:

1. I welcome the proposed requirement in rule 6.5 to provide the power
output used by the entrant. In past BERU contests when I was in the open
category I could have listed my power as 1000 watts which is what the input
power to the final stage of my transmitter was and this was in accordance
with Canadian regulations. But who lists their input power when submitting a
log? My output power was 500 watts which is within Canadian regulations
whereas 1000 watts output power is not according to Industry Canada
publication RBR-4.

2. Having participated in BERU for many years I am AGHAST at proposal
2.10 to let the whole world work Commonwealth stations! I thought that the
purpose of the Commonwealth Contest is to promote friendships amongst
amateurs in the Commonwealth countries. In addition, you will basically
remove those entrants who are running 100 watts to a wire antenna from
contention in making contacts with the rarer Commonwealth prefixes
because non-Commonwealth operators running kilowatt plus stations will be
mainly interested in those rare entities and not the run-of-the-mill
Commonwealth stations (such as VE3s).

3. To whom does proposed rule change 6.9 cater? What is wrong with
remembering that the contest has its roots in the British Empire Radio Union?
In addition, CQ BERU sounds much better on CW than CQ CC.

In summary, proposed change 6.5 is welcome but as far as proposed changes
2.10 and 6.9 are concerned “If it ain’t broke don’t fix it”.

Best regards,
Alan Goodacre VE3HX

White Paper comments fron John, VE3EJ

07 Tuesday Jul 2015

Posted by bobg3pjt in Reports

≈ Leave a comment

Thank you for the opportunity to comment on the proposed rule changes.  My notes are highlighted in red below and are limited to the BERU as this is the only contest on the list that I have experience with.  Best of luck with the ongoing discussions.  73,  John, VE3EJ

2.10. Commonwealth Contest – Change the format so that the World can work the Commonwealth

In my opinion this would completely change the flavor of the contest which has made the BERU so unique.  I do not favor this change as it will effectively end the BERU contest as we have know it for decades.  The BERU will become just another QSO volume events like so many already on the contest calendar.  Don’t destroy the tradition. 

6.8. BERU – To assist identifying QRP stations, remove the requirement to put QRP in the Cabrillo header and add a requirement to enter the power output used when submitting the log

No problem here, whatever makes log processing easier is fine.

6.9. BERU – In the rules, change all references to BERU to Commonwealth Contest and suggest entrants call CQ CC not CQ BERU.

 This is a matter of tradition.  I am OK with the formal rules making reference to “Commonwealth Contest” rather than BERU but I suggest that the tradition of BERU in the “CQ” will be a hard habit to break and frankly for what purpose?  What is the motivation here?  This sounds like an effort to be politically correct. 

White paper feedback from Dave, VO1AU

02 Thursday Jul 2015

Posted by bobg3pjt in Reports

≈ Leave a comment

Edited – Only comments on Commonwealth Contest
Hello RSGB Contests Committee:

I am writing to provide my comments to some of the proposals outlined in the White Paper.

I am a regular participant in the RSGB Commonwealth Contest. I have placed as high as #2 in the Open section. I have entered the BERU from VO1, VO2, VE9, VE2, 9M6 and ZL7. I am an occasional participant in the RSGB IOTA contest, always on expeditions to IOTAs.

I will comment only on the following sections of the White Paper:

1.4. Reduce the entry period for all contests (except IOTA) to 7 days except by prior arrangement
with the contest adjudicator. The entry period for IOTA will remain at 21 days.

Comment: I support this change.

2.1. IOTA – Introduce a 6 hour duration section to IOTA.

Comment: I oppose this change. IOTA has far too many categories.

2.10. Commonwealth Contest – Change the format so that the World can work the Commonwealth

Comment: I oppose this change. The intra-Commonwealth nature of the BERU is its great attraction to me. There are plenty enough contests in the format you suggest, and they are so numerous as to be banal. BERU has a unique attractiveness because it is so different. BERU is my favourite contest, and a change like this is too drastic for my taste.

Counter-comment: If you must do this, please make changes that keep the focus on the Commonwealth for all entrants. One example you might follow is the RAC Canada Day Contest and the Canada Winter Contest:everyone can work everyone for points, but QSOs with a Canadian station are worth five times as many QSO points as with someone outside Canada, and only Canadian provinces and territories count as multipliers. The keeps the focus for all entrants on working Canadians, but if well-meaning station calls you from someplace else, you will still work them. A similar implementation for the Commonwealth would have QSOs with non-Commonwealth stations worth one point, QSOs with Commonwealth stations worth five points, and only Commonwealth Call Areas would count for bonuses or multipliers. This would kill the old BERU and replace it with something hugely different, but it would alleviate the irritation we now cause my ignoring or dismissing non-Commonwealth callers.

6.8. BERU – To assist identifying QRP stations, remove the requirement to put QRP in the Cabrillo header and add a requirement to enter the power output used when submitting the log.

Comment: I support this change.

6.9. BERU – In the rules, change all references to BERU to Commonwealth Contest and suggest entrants call CQ CC not CQ BERU.

Comment: Your proposed changes are superfluous
– You have proposed to remove something that has already been removed. The contest is called the Commonwealth Contest, and rules have reflected that for over forty years. The current rules make no mention of “BERU” except in two URLs. One of these is an RSGB site where a sample Cabrillo-format log can be consulted. The other is G3PJT’s site where one can find additional information on the contest. Change the RSGB site URL if you must, but frankly, who cares about a URL?
– The rules currently do not recommend a method of calling CQ. What you suggest was attempted in the late 1970s, and was almost universally ignored. I will still call CQ BERU, and I am certain that however I call CQ, you will accept and adjudicate my log. You wish to modify the rules to inform participants that many will solicit contacts by calling “CQ BERU” or “CQ CC.”

Thank you for your hard work to keep the RSGB contest programme humming along.

73,

Dave Goodwin
VO1AU / VO2AAA / VE9CB / VE3AAQ
RSGB life member

Subscribe

  • Entries (RSS)
  • Comments (RSS)

Archives

  • April 2023
  • March 2023
  • February 2023
  • January 2023
  • November 2022
  • July 2022
  • June 2022
  • May 2022
  • April 2022
  • March 2022
  • February 2022
  • January 2022
  • December 2021
  • November 2021
  • October 2021
  • July 2021
  • April 2021
  • March 2021
  • February 2021
  • January 2021
  • September 2020
  • April 2020
  • March 2020
  • February 2020
  • January 2020
  • December 2019
  • November 2019
  • April 2019
  • March 2019
  • February 2019
  • January 2019
  • December 2018
  • November 2018
  • October 2018
  • September 2018
  • April 2018
  • March 2018
  • February 2018
  • January 2018
  • November 2017
  • September 2017
  • August 2017
  • July 2017
  • May 2017
  • April 2017
  • March 2017
  • February 2017
  • January 2017
  • December 2016
  • November 2016
  • October 2016
  • September 2016
  • August 2016
  • July 2016
  • June 2016
  • May 2016
  • April 2016
  • March 2016
  • February 2016
  • January 2016
  • November 2015
  • September 2015
  • July 2015
  • June 2015
  • March 2015
  • February 2015
  • January 2015
  • December 2014

Categories

  • DXpeditions
  • HQ Stations
  • News
  • Reports
  • Results
  • Teams
  • Uncategorized

Meta

  • Register
  • Log in

Blog at WordPress.com.

  • Follow Following
    • Commonwealth Contest
    • Join 165 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Commonwealth Contest
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar