2010 Results

VP2parrotJ6blackbirdOnce again the number of logs received continues to grow. The Traveller concept seems to be extremely popular, with the result that many quite exotic DX locations are available for Commonwealth amateurs. Once again, the level of participation from India was remarkable, and many entrants commented that they cannot recall having ever heard so many on the bands at one time! Despite some indications of light at the end of the “tunnel of sunspot minimum”, conditions on 10m were patchy. Many people gratefully grabbed the opportunities available, whilst others, often in the twelve-hour category, missed out completely.
The number of HQ stations active seems to have more-or-less settled now, with eight available in 2010. Excluding those HQ stations, there were 62 valid call areas represented in entrants’ logs, marginally less than last year. A total of 264 entries were received, together with fourteen check-logs.
RESTRICTED SECTION: The Restricted section showed a further significant rise in popularity, with 104 entrants this year.

J6G3PJTFirst place, and the Junior Rose Bowl, goes to long-term enthusiast Bob G3PJT, operating with a J6 prefix from the Caribbean island of Saint Lucia. Peter G3LET was the top UK station, in overall second place, whilst Gary VE1RGB managed third position despite finding no ten-metre contacts.

Nick 5X1NH

Nick 5X1NH drops two places from last year to take fourth place, as does Mike G3IAF in fifth. However Mike does win the John Dunnington Trophy by doing so, as Peter was ineligible having won it in 2009. There was nothing to separate John G4CZB and Geoff G4FKA in joint sixth position, just ahead of Mike G3VYI, who takes eighth spot. Having found 23 QSOs and 14 bonuses on ten metres, Andrew V51YJ is placed at number nine, and it is a real pleasure to welcome an Indian entrant to the top ten in the form of Gajendra VU2BGS.

The highest-placed twelve-hour entrant is Dave G3ZQH who is in equal twelfth position.
OPEN SECTION: Retaining the Senior Rose Bowl this year, with an unassailable lead, was John VE3EJ.

vp2mcc nick vp2mcc ApartmentSecond place goes to Nick G4FAL who achieved a fine score as VP2MCC from Montserrat. Ontario seems to have been the beneficiary of some good propagation this year as, in addition to leader VE3EJ, four more residents gained top-ten ranking – Ron VX3AT in third, Dave VE3OI in seventh, Chris VE3FU who was ninth, and Richard VE3KI who took tenth place. Cyprus was another “hot spot” where good ten-metre openings helped Steve ZC4LI to fourth spot, Andy ZC4VJ to fifth, and Alan P3J to sixth. The remaining eighth position was filled by Dave G3TBK operating as J88DR from Saint Vincent.
GI0RTN G6PZWe have to read down to eleventh place to find the leading UK entrant, G6PZ operated by Gerry GI0RTN, who, nevertheless, is awarded the Col Thomas Rose Bowl. Leading twelve-hour entrant is Cris GM4FAM who is placed thirtieth overall.
HQ STATIONS: Obviously utilising the advantageous conditions previously noted in the Open section, VA3RAC, operated by Bob VE3KZ, takes the honours in the HQ section. gb5cc20102A short distance behind is GB5CC, with Chris GM3WOJ on the key from his Scottish Highland QTH. In an unaccustomed third position is the New Zealand station, where the callsign ZL6HQ was used by a team comprising ZL1AIH, ZL1BHQ and ZL1GO. The remaining entrants were VK4WIA (Keith VK4TT), VE7RAC (Brian VE7JKZ), VO1RAC (Paul VO1HE) and VU2MTT.
MULTI-OPERATOR & ASSISTED SECTION: This year eleven stations entered this section, whether due to DXcluster use, decoding the CW using Skimmer, or as genuine multi-operator stations. Topping the table is Terry G4AMT, followed by two west-coast Canadians – Ralph VE7XF and Les VA7RN.
TWELVE-HOUR AWARDS: The Ross Carey Rose Bowl, awarded to the highest-placed UK station in the 12-hour category (regardless of section), goes to Cris GM4FAM who is placed thirtieth in the Open section.

ve1opThe VP8GQ Trophy, awarded to the equivalent non-UK station goes to Scott VE1OP with his thirty-third place finish in the same section.
COMMONWEALTH TRAVELLER: The Traveller Award is proving to be a major success. Not only do participants invest much time and effort into organising entries from some interesting places, but, knowing that these rare entities are available with less QRM than usual, act as a further attraction to serious and casual entrants alike. The end result is increased activity around the Commonwealth, which is good for everybody. This year’s winner is Nick G4FAL who travelled to operate as VP2MCC from Montserrat where he managed to take second place in the Open section. Another very creditable effort was by Bob J6/G3PJT who won the Restricted section from Saint Lucia. Such dedication should be rewarded, and so both will be receiving a certificate. Other traveller reports are by  J38CW Grenada , 9G5XA Ghana and 5X1NH Uganda.
COMMONWEALTH TEAM CONTEST: Once again, seven teams battled it out to claim bragging rights for another year. Last year’s winners, the Rest-of-the-World, retained their title with a record-breaking 75757 points, but only just! Team Canada took full advantage of conditions to amass 74725 points, an amazing score for a team entirely based north of the equator. Once again, Team Great Britain is third with 59640 points, although their points total has increased. Australia dropped back to fourth position with 52549. Africa gained fifth place with 46693, with New Zealand pressing hard in fifth with 45164, although the latter were unable to field a full team on this occasion. Newcomers in 2009, Team Asia, more than doubled their previous score to 32769, although remaining in seventh.
The team members were –

Team Rest of World: J88DR, J6/G3PJT, VP2MCC, J38CW, ZC4LI, ZC4VJ, P3J, C4Z, VP8NO, ZB2EO
Team Australia: VK6LW, VK2BJ, VK6HG, VK4BUI, VK4EMM, VK6DXI, VK6HZ, VK6AJ, VK6BN, VK2NU
Team Great Britain: G4TSH, G6PZ, GM3POI, G3LET, MD0CCE, G3SJJ, G3KMA, G3WPH, GM4FAM, GW3NJW
Team New Zealand: ZL2BR, ZL1T, ZL1AZE, ZM4G, ZL3TE, ZL3GA, ZL3IO
Team Canada: VE3FU, VX3AT, VE3EJ, VE3KI, VE3OI, VE3UTT, VX7CC, VE1RGB, VO1TA, VY2SS
Team Africa: V51YJ, ZS6KR, ZS1EL, 5X1NH, 3B9WR, ZS4JAN, 5H3EE, 9G5XA, 9J2BO

Team Asia: VU2PTT, 5B4AGN, 9M6XRO, VQ9LA, VU2BGS, VU2CDP, VU2PAI, VU2RMS, VU2TS, VU2UR
gm4yln qrpQRP CERTIFICATE: This year six entrants who indicated that they were using an output power of five watts or less. Receiving the certificate, with a score of 1615 points, is Chris GM4YLN. Last year’s winner, Dave G3YMC, was runner-up with 1435 points, whilst there was a tie for third place between Joseph 9H1CG and Bob VA3RKM who scored 1195. Also in this sub-category are G3NFB and G6CSY.
SELECTED SOAPBOX: On conditions >>> Much improved HF conditions at the expense of 80m (G3LET) >>> 15 metres open for far longer than last year (G3PSM) >>> a great opening on 10m on Sunday morning (P3J) >>> No sign of that early morning opening on 10m at this end! (J38CW) >>> 10m band opened nicely bringing hope for coming months and years (VK6DXI) >>> Conditions on the higher bands were a real improvement over recent years (ZL2BR)>>>Propagation was good on 20+15 although nothing was heard from VK/ZL. 10M never opened. LF propagation was OK but the bands were very noisy probably due to storms to the north of Accra.(9G5XA)

On external factors >>> Had a stomach bug on Friday and had to quit 1730-ish on Saturday (3B9WR) >>> Mains power all contest – a unique miracle! (5X1NH) >>> all fitted around family stuff after new junior op Nathan was born a week before (G4RCD) >>> Lost an hour early on when Police came to investigate robbery which occurred just before the start (J88DR) >>> Aged 97 on 21/04/10 & hands packed up. Only my 64-year-old bug enabled me to make these few QSOs (VK4XA)

On the contest generally >>> Please keep the 12hr category for those of us with families (G0HVQ) >>> Thanks to the travelling fraternity who greatly add to the interest (G3KKP) >>> Canadian stations … can always be relied on to provide a good turnout (G3KMY) >>> Very pleased to work so many UK stations this year (V51YJ) >>> Best BERU in recent years (VA3RAC) >>> first time in this contest – didn’t have much time but liked it very much (VE3MIA) >>> teams add an interesting dimension (VK4EMM) >>> usual problem with non-commonwealth stations calling (VP8NO)VP8NO QSL_5-1

ADJUDICATION  2010 was the year of the robot! The vast majority of entrants submitted their logs without problem, many commenting how easy it was. For those that failed to actually read the rules, and sent their logs as e-mail attachments in the old way, I was lenient. So I submitted those logs to the robot myself, whilst directing the resultant output to the entrant’s own e-mail address. Such generosity may not recur in 2011, so please heed the published rules! Naturally, there were a few questions resulting from robot responses, and these were answered directly. Some of the questions, and their answers, may be of relevance to the wider community, so I will mention them here. Missed and duplicated serial numbers are a fact of life. Although the robot will draw attention to such occurrences, the adjudication process will cope and will not impose penalties. Entrants in the twelve-hour sections should NOT place their operating periods within the body of the Cabrillo file, as this will attract the wrath of the robot. The correct place for such information is in the Soapbox. There is no separate category for QRP entrants, but such adherents will be noted and listed, provided that QRP is included within the Soapbox comments. There are no penalties for duplicate contacts, nor for contacts with stations outside the Commonwealth. The adjudication software will detect these, and disregard them in the re-scoring process. Finally, don’t worry if your favourite software cannot cope with the unique scoring system for this contest – a claimed score is not a requirement. It goes without saying that paper logs are still welcome from those of you who log without computer assistance. There are no plans to change this policy in the future. However, such logs still have to be typed-up to enter the adjudication process, and your assistance in making this task as easy as possible for our volunteers is requested. Firstly, it must be legible! Secondly, it should be a single log in sequential order, not as separate sheets for each band. Thirdly, please do not waste your time sending a “dupe sheet”; it is not required and merely adds unnecessary postal costs for you. My thanks go to Steve G3UFY who did an admirable job in converting paper logs to Cabrillo format this year, despite suffering a painful hand injury. The full  on-line version of these results is available on the Contest Committee website at Commonwealth Contest 2010 Results

Thanks Paul EI5DI, author of the dedicated SDC logging program, for sponsoring prizes for the team competition again this year.

Check logs are gratefully acknowledged from 5B4AGQ, 9M2CNC, G3GMM, G3RWL, G3VQO, G3XMM, G3XQX, G4BYG, G4VSS, GM0AXY, GM4ZUK, MM0GPZ, VE7YL and VU2NKS.

As Les is stepping down from the adjudication we take this opportunity to thank him for a job well done. Under Les’ management the process has become very smooth and automated with prompt and accurate publishing of the results each year.

CALL AREAS ACTIVE IN 2010: 3B8, 3B9, 4S, 5B, 5H, 5N, 5X, 5Z, 6Y, 7P, 7Q, 8P, 9G, 9H, 9J, 9M2, 9M6, 9V, 9Y, A3, C6, G, G-HQ, J3, J6, J8, V5, V8, VE1, VE2, VE3, VE3-HQ, VE4, VE5, VE6, VE7, VE7-HQ, VE9, VK2, VK3, VK4, VK4-HQ, VK5, VK6, VK7, VK8, VO1, VO1-HQ, VP2M, VP8, VQ9, VU, VU-HQ, VY1, VY2, ZB2, ZC4, ZF, ZL1, ZL2, ZL3, ZL4, ZL6, ZL6-HQ, ZS0, ZS1, ZS2, ZS4 and ZS6

NEXT YEAR: The 74th Commonwealth Contest will take place on the 12/13th March 2011, starting at 1000UTC. Please check the website nearer the time to see if there are any changes to the rules for 2011.

Les Allwood G3VQO

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s